What is Julia Child's favourite cake?
Mastering the Art of French Cooking, Volume I puts the malakoff on page 605 and the ladyfingers on page 666. Julia Child wrote the book with Simone Beck and Louisette Bertholle; Alfred A. Knopf published it in 1961.
Her method dips ladyfingers in orange liqueur and water, drains them, lines a cylindrical mold, and alternates almond cream, strawberries and more ladyfingers until the mold is full. Serve the cake with fresh strawberries and lightly whipped cream.
Her verdict on bought fingers is blunt: store-bought ladyfingers are unusable, so the sponge is made at home. That is the clearest difference between a malakoff and a charlotte russe. The russe is a Bavarian cream set with gelatin; the malakoff is almond cream folded with whipped cream and needs no gelatin.
The page that reproduces Child's method prints no exact quantities, so the weights below belong to the adapting blog.
Ingredients and mould
Use a 7-inch mold, a charlotte mold or tube pan, lined with plastic wrap. The other printed recipe uses a 2-quart souffle dish lined with parchment and gives 6 to 8 servings.
Almond cream
- 1 cup / 226 g European butter
- 1 cup / 200 g sugar
- 1 1/4 cups / 150 g toasted almonds, ground
- 1/4 tsp almond extract
- 1/3 cup kirschwasser
Fruit and finish
- 3 cups / 420 g sour cherries
- 2/3 cup / 130 g sugar
- 1/4 cup kirschwasser
- 1 1/4 cups / 296 ml cream with 1 Tbsp confectioners' sugar and 1 tsp vanilla, for Chantilly cream
- toasted almonds, to finish
Ladyfingers and syrup
- 3/4 cup / 82 g cake flour, 1 1/2 tsp espresso powder, 4 eggs separated, 1/2 cup / 100 g superfine sugar, a pinch of salt, 2 tsp vanilla, confectioners' sugar for dusting
- 1/2 cup kirschwasser or cherry juice, plus 1/2 cup water, for dipping
Bought ladyfingers are quick, though Child called them unusable; the sponge is easy enough to make from the ladyfinger recipe.
Where the name comes from
Three explanations of the charlotte name circulate at once, and the sources that print them do not settle on one.
| Explanation | Source | Date it gives | How firmly |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carême created a cold charlotte and named it for his Russian employer, Czar Alexander I. | What's Cooking America; John Ayto, quoted by the Food Timeline | 1802 in Ayto; the site labels the episode "18th Century" although Carême lived 1784–1833 | Hedged with "said to" and "so the story goes" |
| The name honours Queen Charlotte, wife of George III. | What's Cooking America; Wikipedia; Macculloch Hall | Queen Charlotte 1744–1818; no date for the naming | "Some historians"; the TLFi (Trésor de la langue française informatisé) says the proof is lacking and English "charlotte" is not attested before 1855 |
| Cold charlottes are linked to the Russian court, and the name russe is said to come from a banquet for Tsar Alexander I or from the French switch to service à la russe. | Laura the Gastronaut; the Oxford Companion to Food, quoted by the Food Timeline | Carême 1783–1833; no date for the banquet | Hedged with "linked" and "it is said"; the Oxford Companion offers two reasons |
The chill time is just as unsettled.
| Source | Chill | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Julia Child, as reproduced by Laura the Gastronaut | At least six hours | A saucer |
| Food Network | At least 2 hours | None printed |
| Zoë Bakes adaptation | Several hours or overnight, and 24 hours ahead is allowed | A cardboard round and heavy tins |
The malakoff is one member of the charlotte family; the gelatin-set version is at charlotte russe, and a chocolate mousse filling at chocolate charlotte.
Lining and syrup
Two syrups are printed: kirschwasser or cherry juice with an equal volume of water, and orange liqueur with water, 1/4 cup of each in the Food Network version.
- Line the mold with plastic wrap or parchment.
- Dip each ladyfinger in the syrup and drain it briefly.
- Stand the fingers upright around the inside of the mold, close together and with no gaps.
The fingers bake at 190 °C / 375 °F for 15 minutes; Child's method gives about twenty minutes. The Food Network sponge bakes at 350 °F for 15 minutes.
Almond cream and cream fold
Beat the butter and sugar until pale, then work in the ground almonds, almond extract and kirschwasser.
- Beat the soft butter with the sugar.
- Add the ground almonds, almond extract and 1/3 cup kirschwasser.
- Whip the cream to soft peaks and fold it through the almond butter cream.
The Food Network version swaps in 1 3/4 cups toasted hazelnuts and 1/2 cup hazelnut liqueur, and whips 2 cups cream into the filling.
Layering the fruit
Toss the cherries with the sugar and the 1/4 cup kirschwasser.
- Spread a layer of almond cream over the bottom of the lined mold.
- Scatter cherries over the cream.
- Add ladyfingers, then repeat cream, fruit and fingers until the mold is full.
Child's strawberries go in as alternating layers in the same way. The Food Network version stands whole strawberries point down in a ring around the outer edge of each cream layer and uses a full quart.
Finish with the remaining cherries, piped Chantilly cream and toasted almonds. The Food Network tops each rosette with a small strawberry and dusts the sides with coarsely chopped hazelnuts.
Weighted chill and unmolding
Cover the cream with a cardboard round, set heavy tins on it, and chill for several hours or overnight; the cake can be made 24 hours ahead. Child's method weights the top with a saucer and gives at least six hours. The Food Network version prints two hours and no weight.
- Weight the top, then refrigerate the mold for the full time.
- Peel back the lining from the edge of the set cake.
- Turn the mold out onto a chilled plate and lift it away.
Serve cold, with the cream firm and the fruit still holding its shape. The Zoë Bakes adaptation is the one route that brings the cake to room temperature before serving.
Charlotte malakoff FAQ
Why must it be weighted?
The weighted versions press the layers under a saucer or a cardboard round and heavy tins so the cream and fruit compact into a block that holds when the mold is turned over: at least six hours in Child's method, several hours or overnight in the Zoë Bakes adaptation. The Food Network version skips the weight and prints two hours; it is the faster but softer route.
Can I use hazelnuts instead of almonds?
Yes. The Food Network recipe replaces the almonds with 1 3/4 cups ground toasted hazelnuts and the kirschwasser with 1/2 cup hazelnut liqueur, and dusts the sides with coarsely chopped hazelnuts. Child's version uses almonds.