Ingredients and mould
The two printed charlottes share only a biscuit lining. Martha Stewart builds on 5 ounces of semisweet chocolate at 55 to 61 percent cocoa, with 2 egg yolks, ¼ cup sugar, ¼ cup plus 2 tablespoons milk cooked to a custard, and 1 cup cream: ¼ cup of it simmers into the custard, the rest is whipped. Good Housekeeping UK uses 200 g dark chocolate, 125 g butter, 6 eggs, 75 g caster sugar and two 175 g packs of sponge fingers. Tins as printed.
| Recipe | Tin | Lining | Set | Minimum chill | Yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Martha Stewart | 6-by-3-inch cake ring | Cocoa ladyfingers, baked in-house | ½ teaspoon gelatin plus 1 cup cream, ¼ simmered, ¾ whipped | 4 hours, or overnight | 1 6-inch charlotte |
| Good Housekeeping UK | 20.5 cm springform, base inverted | Bought sponge fingers dipped in water | Raw whites whipped stiff; no gelatin or cream | 6 hours, or overnight | 8 servings |
The open ring is 3 inches deep; the springform's depth is unstated, and it carries the longer chill. Martha Stewart prints a yield of 1 6-inch charlotte; Good Housekeeping UK prints 8 servings.
The cocoa-cookie lining
The cocoa lining is made, not bought: Martha Stewart pipes a 3½-inch ladyfinger template and three 5-inch rounds from a cocoa batter (1 cup plus 2 tablespoons flour, ¼ cup plus 1 tablespoon Dutch cocoa, 6 eggs) and bakes them about 14 minutes at 350 °F. About 16 fingers stand upright in the ring, and fingers and cake are brushed with ⅓ cup dark rum boiled with ⅓ cup sugar. Good Housekeeping UK softens bought sponge fingers in water, rings them round the tin edge and covers the bottom; no spirit.
Chocolate mousse
The fillings set by different means. Martha Stewart simmers ¼ cup of the cream into the chocolate custard, stirs in ½ teaspoon gelatin bloomed in 2 tablespoons milk, and whips the remaining ¾ cup cream to soft peaks, folding it in; the cream carries the set as much as the gelatin. Good Housekeeping UK folds cooled chocolate and butter into 6 raw yolks, then folds in the 6 whites whipped to stiff peaks. No gelatin, no cream: cold alone sets it. Because the eggs stay raw, it asks for Red Lion stamped eggs; treated or pasteurized shell eggs are the US equivalent.
Chill and unmould
Chill minimums follow the mould: 4 hours in the open ring, 6 hours in the springform; both accept overnight, and Martha Stewart's filling can stand up to 1 day before assembly. Unmould only when the filling is firm: onto a platter, lift the ring, peel the parchment; the springform unclips. Guidance for custard and chiffon pies gives 3 to 4 days refrigerated at 40 °F (4 °C) or below, and says not to freeze.
Decoration and serving
Both finishes are plain: 1 cup cream whipped with ¼ cup confectioners' sugar and chocolate shavings in one; grated chocolate or chocolate powder in the other. Serve cold. A fruit-set version belongs at the raspberry charlotte, which sets a cooked curd on a chiffon border; for almond cream see the charlotte malakoff; the family page lists the other moulded desserts.
Chocolate charlotte FAQ
What spirit goes into the soaking syrup?
Dark rum. Martha Stewart boils ⅓ cup dark rum with ⅓ cup sugar and brushes it over fingers and cake. Good Housekeeping UK dips the fingers in water, so it has no spirit.
Can I make it a day ahead?
Yes. Martha Stewart's filling can be refrigerated up to 1 day before assembly, and both recipes allow an overnight chill once built. The nearest printed keep-time is 3 to 4 days refrigerated.